Skip to content
Wednesday, November 11, 2026
889992778 Insights

If the Blacksmith Has a Countless Detractors, I Stand as One of Them.

Upon learning that Clint from the beloved farming sim was revealed as one of the two marriage candidates in the upcoming version 1.7, I exclaimed incredulously, “Him?!” The news consumed me for hours afterward — should Clint possess a million haters (and he does), I am one of them; if he has zero enemies, it means I've departed this earthly realm. However, after sleeping on it, I now realize that perhaps that’s exactly the point — no resident in more dire need of a second chance than Clint.

The Source of the Dislike

Pelican Town's blacksmith has drawn a lot of ire for a long time, primarily because of his obsession with Emily, a fellow marriage candidate. During his first heart events, he asks the player about how to talk to women, then behaves with painful awkwardness around Emily, who is taking his order in the saloon, then laments to the player that he’s “finished.” He often appears defeatist, desperate, and somewhat unsettling — to many, he feels like a classic “nice guy” who becomes upset at even the slightest perceived rejection.

A Common Response

My reaction to this part of the new update was anything but solitary. There have been a host of grievances, disappointment over who should've been chosen instead, and endless jokes following the announcement. One social media user wrote, “Picture finishing the worst shift of your life and learning Clint is now someone you can marry in Stardew Valley.”

A Spark of Potential

However, part of the conversation on the matter offers a brighter perspective and — reluctantly — makes a few good points. Some fans have compared the idea of Clint’s redemption to that of Haley. Haley starts as extremely mean when you first meet her, but softens over time through friendship, a process some have referred to as “improving Haley to make her better to be around.” Clint possesses much that same potential, but with a crucial distinction: he makes many gamers the ick.

Screenshot: ConcernedApe

The 'Ick' Factor

I’ve personally always found Haley’s early rudeness easier to stomach than Clint’s one-sided obsession with a woman who doesn’t reciprocate, and many other players seem to feel the same. It’s hard to place exactly precisely why — perhaps it’s just a situation lots of people can identify with, provoking a stronger gut response to Clint. This discomfort Clint possesses undeniably presents an additional challenge in him being seen as an appealing romantic partner, but that’s arguably yet another reason the character desperately needs a turnaround.

A Hint of Understanding

I will admit that, as many times as I’ve shouted about how much Clint needs to stop being weird, he can evoke some level of sympathy. Maybe not during the notorious bush-hiding incident, but in general, he comes across as a sad, lonely man. As one observer noted, “He is a man looking for someone to reciprocate his feelings, and that is what this candidacy offers him.”

A Place for Redemption

The blacksmith's upcoming romance path may not be for all types of Stardew Valley fan, but it serves a purpose. However skeptical I am about ever viewing him a potential husband, the game's creator is a wonderful writer with a knack for adding layers to every character in Pelican Town. Similar to previous expansions, the new version appears as a substantial new addition with a lot of love at its heart, and his character arc is surely not being done flippantly. Maybe with Clint’s new chance at love, players can at last put their hate for him aside and place it where it truly belongs — toward Pierre.

Written by

Nancy Williams

A digital strategist and tech writer with over a decade of experience in analyzing emerging technologies and their impact on society.

889992778 Insights

Type to search articles.